Published on YaleGlobal Online Magazine (http://yaleglobal.yale.edu)
Home > US Lags in Race for Tech Talent

US Lags in Race for Tech Talent

The US is highly protectionist on labor and jobs. The country remains a top destination among skilled talent because of its opportunities in education, angel investors and markets. But regulations on visas that allow immigrants to work at US firms increasingly lead to bottlenecks in the application process and career obstacles for individuals in a highly mobile global market for top talent. US law allows no more than 7 percent of the permanent-residency visas to any one nationality, yet Chinese and Indian workers make up half the skilled pool, reports educator and author Vivek Wadhwa. Likewise, US laws are not amenable for the tech startups that begin with a handful of employees. Australia, Canada and the UK are streamlining policies to welcome such entrepreneurs. Chile is offering startup funds and other subsidies to attract tech workers. Countries count on talent to invigorate economies, and the race is on. – YaleGlobal

US Lags in Race for Tech Talent

US sets up roadblocks; other nations offer speedy path for residency to skilled tech workers
Vivek Wadhwa
YaleGlobal, 26 October 2012
Visas to innovate: Anand (left) and Shikha Chhatpar innovated as students and, denied visas, they run their US startups from India (top); Vinod Khosla, cofounder of Sun Microsystems, came to the US on H-1B visa

SAN FRANCISCO: From all appearances Silicon Valley is booming, but it’s a deceptive image. The sources of innovation which have always powered the Valley are seeping away, taking with them the lifeblood of a giant technology wealth machine. A steady stream of immigrant innovators are saying goodbye to America and heading home.

Rents and salaries are soaring in Silicon Valley. The tables are full for breakfast at Buck’s in Woodside and The Creamery in San Francisco with venture capitalists quizzing young masters of the digital universe in search of the next Facebook or Instagram. Across the Bay Area, free lunch is served, preferably organic and local. But many talented individuals no longer find the US an attractive place.

While everyone remains busy counting the many billions in future IPO earnings or big buyouts by Google and Microsoft, few have noticed that the immigrant entrepreneurs who have increasingly driven technology sector growth in Silicon Valley are leaving for greener pastures. Google, Instagram, Tesla, Yammer, Sun Microsystems and PayPal all count immigrants among their key founders. So signs that the tide of immigrant founders flowing into the US technology sector have reversed must be taken seriously by anyone who cares about maintaining the country’s global leadership in this economically critical area.

AnnaLee Saxenian, dean of the School of Information at University of California, Berkeley, documented that in 1998, Chinese and Indian computer scientists and engineers were running one-quarter of the region's high-tech firms. In that year alone, these firms accounted for nearly $17 billion in sales and more than 58,000 jobs. In 2006 and 2007, I worked with Saxenian to update this research. We surveyed 2052 tech companies founded between 1995 and 2005; the proportion of immigrant-founded companies in Silicon Valley had increased to 52.4 percent. Nationwide, the proportion was 25.3 percent, and these companies generated sales of $52 billion and employed 450,000.

A 2012 survey shows significant decline in
the percentage of tech companies headed by immigrants in Silicon Valley.

That research received significant media coverage. Not surprisingly, we began to receive emails from young immigrant entrepreneurs. Rather than telling us how great it was to launch a business in Silicon Valley,  or the US in general, a significant portion of those missives contained tales of visa hell and immigration limbo. From their viewpoint, the free-flowing ideation and the fast company formation of Silicon Valley did not match the legal red tape required for people not born in America to start and run a business in this country.

During spring and summer of 2012, our research team conducted a follow-up survey of 2042 tech companies with at least $1 million in revenues, the latest and most comprehensive survey to date on the topic. Like previous surveys, we included a significant cohort of companies from Silicon Valley and the Bay Area. Our research team found significant decline in the percentage of technology companies headed by immigrants in Silicon Valley and signs of the beginning of a drop in other parts of the country.

The drop, reversing more than two decades of increases, is troubling. More troubling still, the drop occurred precisely when the country should have experienced rapid increase in immigrant entrepreneurship. During the late 1990s and the early 2000s, the US government dramatically raised the number of immigrant tech workers allowed to enter this country with H-1B visas from roughly 65,000 to 195,000, in response to the Y2K crisis and a boom in the technology industry.

US regulations on
H-1B visas result in bottlenecks that chain skilled immigrants to employer-sponsored jobs.

These visas are the most common pathway to permanent residency in America for skilled immigrants. Silicon Valley remains the premiere destination for skilled workers in the US. Outside of Wall Street, engineers and technologists in the Valley earn the highest salaries of almost any profession. There should be a large upswing in immigrant entrepreneurship in Silicon Valley, yet the very opposite appears to be occurring.

Many factors contribute to this drop. The slowdown in the US economy has contrasted with still-growing economies in China and India, the home countries of the largest percentages of immigrant founders. This is compounded by the challenges that immigrant tech founders face in obtaining visas.

Indian and Chinese H-1B holders face waits of 10 years or more to attain a green card or permanent residency. Once starting the process, they can stay. Current US immigration law allocates no more than 7 percent of the permanent residency visas to any one nationality, and Chinese and Indian immigrants comprise far more than half of the skilled immigrant labor pool. The result is a massive, growing bottleneck that chains skilled immigrants to employer-sponsored jobs. To make matters worse, their spouses are often as qualified as visa holders, yet prohibited from working in the US at all.

This bottleneck has created an enormous pool of highly skilled workers and families waiting for green cards—with no guarantees. The workers could wait for green cards for the most productive parts of their career and be forced to leave with nothing. US laws mandate that if a H-1B worker gets laid off, he or she must leave the country immediately. Even skilled workers who start companies that may provide employment to US workers can’t secure US work visas. Entrepreneurs who pay taxes and provide much needed US technology jobs are forced to shutter businesses due to Draconian immigration policies. For example, Anand and Shikha Chhatpar started two companies that employed several workers and paid more than $250,000 in taxes. Yet the US government forced them to stay in India where they have created jobs.

Other governments
have taken notice of
US immigration-policy failings – and compete for skilled tech workers.

Many other talented immigrants that do obtain the right to work in the US via H-1Bs are trapped into barren career trajectories that undersell their talents. These workers can only work for the companies that sponsor their visas. Employers know they’re less likely to lose these workers than more mobile American citizens, so they offer lower salary increases and keep them in less challenging jobs. That same immigrant is legally prevented from engaging in any outside work, stifling the creative impulses of some of the most highly-skilled workers in the US economy, sometimes permanently.

Other governments have taken notice of US immigration-policy failings. Australia, a country of 22 million, hands out nearly as many employment-based green cards for permanent residence each year. The US, Canada, Germany, the UK and Israel, among others, have set up streamlined visa policies to award skilled technology workers a fast path to permanent residency. Chile has taken the radical step of offering $40,000 to fund startups relocating to the country, along with subsidies for office space and initial employee hires.

The irony of all this is that the US remains the overwhelming destination of choice for founding a company. The startup ecosystem and institutional knowledge of how to start companies runs deep, allowing for lightning-fast transition from idea to product to sales. As Alex Salkever and I explain in our book, The Immigrant Exodus, with only a few simple changes to policies, the US government could reverse this decline. The changes would cost US taxpayers practically nothing, and accelerate job creation and innovation without taking away jobs from native-born Americans. One simple program – a startup visa for foreigners to launch companies in this country – could quickly create hundreds of thousands new jobs.

For now, the US has a protectionist labor market for technology skills. By opening up this labor market, we would ensure that Silicon Valley and other tech hubs continue to provide the spark needed to dig the economy out of its deep hole.

 

Vivek Wadhwa is vice president of academics and innovation at Singularity University; fellow, Arthur & Toni Rembe Rock Center for Corporate Governance, Stanford University; director of research at the Center for Entrepreneurship and Research Commercialization at the Pratt School of Engineering,  Duke University; and distinguished visiting scholar, Halle Institute of Global Learning, Emory University. He is the author of Immigrant Exodus: Why America Is Losing the Global Race to Capture Entrepreneurial Talent. Click here for an excerpt.

Rights:Copyright © 2012 Yale Center for the Study of Globalization.

Comments on this Article

30 October 2012
C'mon VW, you know better. Unemployment rates in STEM occupations is running 2-3 times full employment levels. Several studies have concluded that we're only employing about a third of US citizen STEM grads to do STEM work.
Your own studies reported that US STEM workers were better, by every measure. US Dept. of Labor classifies a large majority of H-1B recipients as in the bottom quartile in terms of "skills". Other, more academic studies concluded that only between 2% and 5% of H-1B grantees are above average or doing above-average work. Examination of pay shows that even the "best of the best of the best" of H-1B recipients are paid a small fraction of 1% above the median.
I don't care whether they're green or purple or have horizontal stripes. What matters is that the US government is not running proper background investigations on applicants for student or guest-work or exchange visas, nor on applicants for green cards, and there are essentially no minimal standards. Even the standards for O visas have gotten severely eroded over the last several decades. With over 117,400 H-1B visas issued through the State Department in FY2010, and an early estimate for FY2011 at nearly 130K it's clear that no one is upholding any standards that mean anything.
-jgo , Florida
29 October 2012
Excellent post on Work force of Expatriates in US.
Dr.A.Jagadeesh Nellore(AP),India
E-mail: anumakonda.jagadeesh@gmail.com
-Anumakonda , Nellore(AP),India
27 October 2012
I agree with Denise.
The White American parasite con game is over to attract overseas talent and use overseas talent to suppress Middle East and Asia.
The Indians r going home to clean the sewage pipes after being fooled by colonial masters for 100 years or more.
The sewage is already festering in America.
Indian sewerage is good.
-Rajan , Malaysia
26 October 2012
What a load of crap. Anti American, anti White agitpropr GARBAGE. White American males are virtually shut OUT of formerly top flight universities, and employments, by White hating Cultural Marxists vermin, who promote anything that is NOT White into top slots, in service of the False God of Diveristy . If Indian engineers are SO brilliant, why have thet figured out how to manage something as basic as sewage? India is literally dorwing in their own feces.
The Dark Orcs simply want to get what Whitey's created. All they will ever do here is recreate the garbage dump they hail from . NOTHING takes the place of White.
-Denise , USA