Published on YaleGlobal Online Magazine (http://yaleglobal.yale.edu)
Home > Wary of China, Its Southern Neighbors Court India

Wary of China, Its Southern Neighbors Court India

China’s rapid ascent, along with the flexing of its muscles, has worried neighbors. They chafe at becoming too dependent, and a loose, yet perceptible balancing coalition aimed at curbing China has emerged. With the United States reorganizing its own priorities, India is viewed as an ideal partner for providing strategic balancing, explains Harsh V. Pant, a defense specialist at King’s College. The region’s fast-growing economies expect open sea lanes in the South China Sea and the Indian Ocean for trade, security or energy exploration. Pant analyzes Burma’s and Vietnam’s attempts to push back China’s attempts to impose rules: Vietnam has arranged naval cooperation with India and cited international law to do joint exploration in the South China Sea; To improve ties with the West, Burma has opened talks with its opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi and declared amnesty for political prisoners. Visits to India by leaders of Burma and Vietnam also show a desire to balance relations with diverse players. Players respect China’s rise, but also want to organize and leverage power against the region’s giant. Harsh concludes that the region’s great power politics have just begun. – YaleGlobal

Wary of China, Its Southern Neighbors Court India

Vietnam and Burma’s opening towards India dovetails with India’s Look East Policy
Harsh V. Pant
YaleGlobal, 28 October 2011
Balancing act: India's Prime Minister Manmohan Singh receives Burma's U Thein Sein (above) and Vietnam's Truong Tan Sang; all look for counterweight to China

LONDON: China’s growing power and muscle-flexing vis-à-vis its neighbors have now resulted in a regional balancing effort. Earlier this month presidents of China’s southern neighbors, Burma and Vietnam, made official visits to India – as much recognition of India’s growing economic and political heft as acknowledgement that India is a good bet as they seek strategic balance in a region transformed by China’s rapid ascent.

This is a time of great turmoil in the Asian strategic landscape, and India is trying to make itself relevant to the regional states. With its political and economic rise, Beijing has started dictating the boundaries of acceptable behavior to its neighbors, thereby laying bare the costs of great power politics. In July, an Indian warship on a friendly visit to Vietnam reported an unidentified Chinese radio warning when it was about 45 nautical miles off the Vietnamese coast. Tensions are rising between China and smaller states in East Asia and Southeast Asia over territorial issues. The US and its allies have already started reassessing their regional strategies, and a loose anti-China balancing coalition is emerging.

India’s role becomes critical in such an evolving balance of power. As Singapore’s elder-statesman Lee Kuan Yew has argued, he would like India to be “part of the Southeast Asia balance of forces” and “a counterweight [to China] in the Indian Ocean.”

A loose anti-China balancing coalition is emerging. India’s role
is critical in an evolving balance of power.

Other regional states, too, are keen on a more pro-active Indian role in the region. And the visits of Vietnamese President Truong Tan Sang and Burmese President Thein Sein to India should be viewed in this broader context. Both Vietnam and Burma have hit a rough patch in their ties with China. China has sparred with regional states including the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Taiwan, asserting its “indisputable sovereignty” over the South China Sea. Some like the Philippines and Vietnam have pushed back. Philippines President Benigno Aquino Jr. told his nation: “We do not wish to increase tensions with anyone, but we must let the world know that we are ready to protect what is ours.” Ever mindful of not provoking China, Vietnam has sent its top party leader to China and the president to India, but has made it clear that it wants the US and India to counterbalance Chinese power.

In September, when Beijing told New Delhi that its permission was needed for India’s state-owned oil and gas firm to explore energy on two Vietnamese blocks in the South China Sea, Vietnam quickly cited the 1982 United Nations Convention of the Law of the Sea to claim that blocks 127 and 128 were in Vietnamese territorial waters. New Delhi supported Hanoi’s claims and has made it clear that its state-owned firm would continue to explore in the South China Sea. This rare display of spine has helped India strengthen its profile in the region and its relationship with Vietnam in particular.

The two nations also have high stakes in ensuring sea-lane security in the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea. Given that Vietnam and India use similar Russian and erstwhile Soviet weapons systems – from submarines to jet fighters – Hanoi has been seeking collaboration with New Delhi on defense. Talks are ongoing for India to sell the BrahMos supersonic cruise missile, developed by an Indo-Russian joint venture. Such collaboration could allow Vietnam to acquire military muscle and improve deterrence against China.

Vietnam and Burma have high stakes in ensuring sea-lane security in the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea.

Naval cooperation between Vietnam and India remains the focus with Vietnam giving India the right to use its port in the south, Nha Trang, situated close to the strategically significant Cam Ranh Bay. During Sang’s visit to India, the two sides reiterated the need to enhance cooperation in ensuring safety and security of the region’s sea lanes and launched a security dialogue. To give strong economic foundation to the bilateral ties, it was also decided to increase the trade target to $7 billion by 2015 from the present $2.7 billion.

Burma too has made its own overtures to India. President Then Sein has pursued a range of reforms in the domestic realm that include opening substantive talks with opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi, declaration of amnesty for political prisoners and cancellation of the Chinese-funded Myitsone Dam project. These efforts could be viewed as an attempt to seek a rapprochement with the democratic world, and that may be why for his first visit abroad as president of a nominal civilian government, Thein Sein chose India.

During his visit, Then Sein sought greater Indian investment in Burma’s energy sector even as the two nations agreed to expand cooperation in oil and gas exploration, open border trade, and speed up construction of natural gas pipelines. India, which is investing in the Kaladan multimodal transport system, connecting India’s eastern seaboard to its northeastern states through Myanmar, further offered $500 million in credits for infrastructure projects.

While India is under pressure from the West to demonstrate democratic credentials, its strategic interests have been winning out in relations with Burma in recent years. Due to such strategic interests, New Delhi has only gently nudged the Burmese junta on the issue of democracy, gradually gaining a sense of trust at the highest echelons of Burma’s ruling elite. India would be loath to lose this relationship. As such, India remains opposed to Western sanctions on the country. Burma’s recent moves towards democratic transition will give India a larger strategic space to maneuver, and compared to Beijing, New Delhi will be a more attractive partner for Naypyidaw as it tries to find a modus vivendi with the West.

Smaller states in East Asia reach out to India for trade, diplomacy and, potentially, as a key regional balancer.

India is emerging as a serious player in the Asian strategic landscape as smaller states in East Asia reach out to it for trade, diplomacy and, potentially, as a key regional balancer.  The “Look East” policy initiated by one of the most visionary prime ministers India has ever had, P.V. Narasimha Rao, is now the cornerstone of India’s engagement with the world’s most economically dynamic region. India’s Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has made it clear that his government’s foreign-policy priority will be east and southeast Asia, poised for sustained growth in the 21st century.

China is too big and too powerful to be ignored by the regional states. But the states in China’s vicinity are now seeking to expand their strategic space by reaching out to other regional and global powers. Smaller states in the region are now looking to India to act as a balancer in view of China’s growing influence and America’s anticipated retrenchment from the region in the near future, while larger states see India as an attractive engine for regional growth. To live up to its full potential and meet the region’s expectations, India must do a more convincing job of emerging as a credible strategic partner of the region. Neither India nor the regional states in East Asia have incentive to define their relationship in opposition to China. But they are certainly interested in leveraging their ties with other states to gain benefits from China and bring a semblance of equality in their relationships. Great power politics in the region have only just begun.

 

Harsh V. Pant is a Reader in International Relations at King’s College London in the Department of Defence Studies. His recent books include “The China Syndrome” (HarperCollins) and “The US-India Nuclear Pact: Policy, Process, and Great Power Politics” (Oxford University Press).

Rights:Copyright © 2011 Yale Center for the Study of Globalization

Comments on this Article

3 November 2011
A note to Karim:
Have you been practising the art of Kow-Towing. Might become useful when China becomes a hyper-power.
-Rao , Canada
2 November 2011
Glad to see the rise of India and China. The world is returning to the past. Prior to the Colonialism of the world by Barbarians. Where two giants that's India and China not only co-existed peacefully but also were the two civilization nations that were wealthy as well. Finally that is happening. This time there is the need to have military power due to the communists in China. But finally as time passes lets all hope that the Communist will also lose power along with their rampant capitalist practices in economy squeezing out the poor Chinese men.
-Victor , India
1 November 2011
I hope Indians get three meals a day every day.
-Dorjee , Lhasa
31 October 2011
A poverty ,caste stricken,religious division ,ethnic and language divide and naxalite driven and independent fighting states in N.E. India (Assam,Mizoram,Khalistan,etc) acting as a "check" on China is a self delusional joke by the West and upper caste Indians.
India is a British colonial tailor made suit.
Give us a better joke in self delusionment.
India is surrounded by states that dont even trust India.Nepal,Pakistan,Bangla Desh,Sri Lanka,Burma.
-hector , singapore
31 October 2011
hard to understand india ambition about China? did india want a 2nd war with china.we want peace not arms race in south and east asia.
-usman karim , pakistan