Published on YaleGlobal Online Magazine (http://yaleglobal.yale.edu)
Home > Obama Visits China-Tilting Cambodia

Obama Visits China-Tilting Cambodia

Barack Obama is the first sitting US president to visit Cambodia and Burma. Both nations have close ties with China, and the contrast in welcomes for Obama was stark: Burmese lined streets and cheered, and Burma officials assured the president on ongoing reform. In Cambodia – which hosted the East Asian Summit attended by Obama, heads of state of ASEAN members and others in the region – the meetings between Hun Sen and Obama were tense and included private discussions on human rights, explains journalist Sebastian Strangio. Banners outside the Peace Palace welcomed one nation and one leader, China and Wen Jiabao, but not far away protesters hefted SOS signs with small photos of Obama. China may have emerged as summit winner – for example, the summit’s closing statement avoided mention of disputed maritime and territorial rights in the South China Sea. But Hun Sen has a knack for playing major powers off one another, and the US is engaged in a long-term strategy for building influence in Southeast Asia via trade and security. – YaleGlobal

Obama Visits China-Tilting Cambodia

Authoritarian Hun Sen plays the US off China, but the US takes long-term view
Sebastian Strangio
YaleGlobal, 7 December 2012
Cambodia in the middle: President Barack Obama extends a limp hand to Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen (top); happier relations with China’s Premier Wen Jiabao

PHNOM PENH: If body language is any predictor, President Barack Obama did not enjoy his short trip to Cambodia to attend the recent East Asia Summit. The unsmiling president joined routines with other participating heads of governments his visit aimed at winning friends and influencing others against a rising China. Still, long-term US involvement in the country’s economy and security may yet produce results.

Before the summit, Obama met privately with summit host, Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen, 60, and chided him on human rights issues, including recent land seizures, jailed political dissenters and the need for next year’s national elections to be free and fair. The meeting was described as “tense.” According to an aide who briefed reporters, Obama contrasted Cambodia’s authoritarian creep with Burma’s moves towards reform, warning that human rights abuses could be an impediment to a “deeper relationship with the United States.”

Obama’s visit to Cambodia, the first by a sitting US president, was preceded by calls for him to publicly address human rights. A Human Rights Watch report released before the trip recounted the unsolved killings of around 300 labor leaders, journalists, and opposition leaders during Hun Sen’s 27-year rule. Local activists also highlighted the self-exile of opposition leader Sam Rainsy on what many say are trumped-up charges and a recent crackdown on government critics and residents protesting forced evictions.

Obama seemed to stake out a middle way on human rights, discussing them behind closed doors but maintaining public silence.

Observing Obama’s chilly visit, Don Jameson, a former diplomat who served at the US Embassy in Phnom Penh in the early 1970s, said Obama seemed to stake out a middle way on human rights, discussing them behind closed doors but maintaining a public silence, possibly an effort to assuage  activists who criticized him for making the stop in Cambodia at all. Jameson observed that the remarks’ impact was limited to the international press. Domestically, Hun Sen basked in the legitimacy conferred by Obama’s visit; human rights issues received little coverage in the government-aligned press. “As long as he has China on his side,” Jameson said, “Hun Sen seems confident that he can weather any storm and does not need to be concerned about what the US thinks.”

Not far from the Peace Palace, protesters released balloons and signs with the international distress signal, SOS, and small photos of Obama.

Lao Mong Hay, a Phnom Penh–based rights activist, welcomed the president’s comments to Hun Sen, expressing hope that they might lead to new emphasis on human rights. “Cambodia cannot afford to have strained relations with the United States,” he said, adding that the country relies on the US as an export market for its garments, giving the US “strategic leverage.” In 2011, according to the Garment Manufacturers Association in Cambodia, the country exported $2.06 billion worth of garments and textiles to the US, more than half of its total; the industry employs an estimated 350,000 workers. Cambodia’s garment exports to the US also make up a massive proportion over its overall exports, which totaled $4.87 billion last year. This stands in contrast to the wide trade deficit with China. In 2011, the $2.5 billion in two-way trade between Cambodia and China consisted overwhelmingly of imports of Chinese machinery, electronics, food, cars and medicines.

Cambodia relies on the US as an export market for garments, more than half that industry’s total, giving the US “strategic leverage.”

Whether the US chooses to use its leverage remains an open question. Obama’s landmark trip to Asia was a key step in Washington’s much-vaunted pivot toward Asia, an effort to bolster military, economic and political relationships as a counterweight to China’s rising influence in the region. Over the past decade, China has poured billions of dollars of “no-strings attached” loans and investments into Cambodia, transforming its physical infrastructure and reducing its dependence on Western development assistance tied to democratic and good governance reforms

In return, Cambodia does China’s bidding on a range of issues. It has deported to China Uighur asylum seekers, given vocal support to the One-China Policy and backed China’s position on negotiations over the South China Sea dispute. Two large green banners welcomed visiting dignitaries to Phnom Penh’s Peace Palace for the summit meetings, listing one leader and one country: “Welcome Prime Minister Wen Jiabao!” proclaimed one banner. “Long Live the People’s Republic of China!” read the other.

Hun Sen has played this game for years. US-Cambodia relations have steadily improved since July 1997, when he overthrew co–prime minister, Prince Norodom Ranariddh, in a violent coup de force. But as Hun Sen consolidated power in the early 2000s, Washington began to reengage. In August 2005, restrictions on US military assistance to Cambodia were lifted; in 2007, the US resumed direct foreign assistance, making Cambodia the third largest recipient of US aid in East Asia after Indonesia and the Philippines. This renewed commitment was symbolized by the December 2005 inauguration of a new $47 million US Embassy complex in Phnom Penh.

Then came the Obama administration’s pivot to Asia. In 2009, Cambodia and the US exchanged defense attachés, and Defense Minister Tea Banh visited Washington for talks about building up ties between the US military and the Royal Cambodian Armed Forces (RCAF). Angkor Sentinel, an annual joint US-Cambodian military exercise, was inaugurated in 2010, and three days before Obama’s arrival last week, Defense Secretary Leon Panetta met with Tea Banh in Siem Reap and reaffirmed US military commitment to Cambodia.

According to Carl Thayer, the US is building relationships with those considered to have influence now and in the future.

Carl Thayer, a professor at the Australia Defense Forces Academy in Canberra, said that despite the lack of any real terrorist threat in Cambodia today, counterterrorism and defense cooperation allows the US to preserve a measure of influence as the country moves further into China’s orbit. “The US has an ‘in’ on the security and defense side that China really does not have,” he said. “Since [counterterrorism] is an already existing program it would have normative approval in the United States as a place to go, to keep some avenues of American influence open.”

Casting its eye to the longer term, the US also moves to establish strong relationships with Hun Sen’s eldest son and heir apparent. Hun Manet was given a place at West Point military academy, graduating in 1999. The 35-year-old is a RCAF major-general and commands the National Counter-Terrorism Special Force established with US assistance in 2008.

In August, at the close of Vector Balance Canoe, another joint military exercise, US Ambassador William E. Todd singled out Manet for his “outstanding job as the commanding officer of such a fine unit,” and reiterated that “America has been committed to Cambodia, is committed to Cambodia now, and will be committed to Cambodia long into the future.” Describing Manet as “a rising future star,” Thayer notes, “America’s very carefully building up relationships with people who are considered to have influence now, and are likely to have even greater influence in future.”

The chilly visit may strain relations, but in the long-run, the two countries will likely see benefits of closer ties. For the US, there is the need to offset a rising China, forcing the former to take a patient approach on human rights issues. For Cambodia, as always, there is the weight of history as a small nation vulnerable to powerful outside forces. It may be that as China’s influence grows Hun Sen will recall an adage often cited by Prince Norodom Sihanouk as he struggled to maintain Cambodia’s neutrality during the Cold War: “When two elephants fight, it is the grass that suffers.” In the end, the economic and military weight of the US may persuade Hun Sen and his successors to slide towards a more balanced position.

Sebastian Strangio is a journalist based in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, covering Asia.
Rights:Copyright © 2012 Yale Center for the Study of Globalization

Comments on this Article

13 December 2012
I've been to Cambodia several times and love the country and her people. Hun Sen is a child soldier really, who knows that brutal force is the shortest distance between two points. That is why he has remained unchallenged all these years. I find it interesting that there's no mention of Vietnam's huge influence on the country and Vietnam's relationship with China. It's no secret that Vietnam needs and wants to expand into Cambodia which is why there are more Vietnamese in Cambodia than any other race. I'm wondering if Obama visited Vietnam and if not why ? For Obama to preach to Hun Sen about human rights is ludicrous. For it is Obama who kills American citizens in foreign countries whom the U.S. is not even at war with, via drone attacks and without a fair trial. Obama also resigned into law the Bush/Cheney expanded powers for the National Security Council removing the habeus corpus allowing the administration to imprison American citizens indefinitely without trial. The U.S. under the Nixon/Kissinger regime pressured the UN to give Cambodia's only seat at the UN to the Khmer Rouge when Hun Sen was living in the forest in the north east of Cambodia. It's all theatre people. No mention if Cambodia is making the U.S. pay for their garments with Chinese Yuan..........yet ! LOL !
-Len Graceeffo , Edmonton AB Canada