Published on YaleGlobal Online Magazine (http://yaleglobal.yale.edu)
Home > Pakistan and the Afghanistan End Game – Part I

Pakistan and the Afghanistan End Game – Part I

As the US and NATO forces prepare for their gradual withdrawal from Afghanistan, a struggle for influence by Afghanistan’s neighbors has been intensifying and its impact may be felt in an increased terrorist threat from Pakistan-backed groups. In the first of a two-part series on the Afghanistan end game, author Ahmed Rashid discusses Pakistan’s two-pronged approach towards its neighbors on the east and west. As Afghanistan emerges as a proxy battleground for India and Pakistan, Pakistan seeks a bigger say in any settlement in Afghanistan while allowing increased terrorist attacks on Indian interests there as well as in Kashmir. Pakistan fears Indian presence and influence in Afghanistan will be used to foment an insurgency in Balochistan, a province of Pakistan. India fears that the emergence of an Afghan-Pakistani Taliban alliance with Al Qaeda would intensify a challenge to its rule in Kashmir. Hence, it wants to prevent Pakistan from becoming the fulcrum for any talks between the Taliban and the Karzai government. To complicate matters further, the US remains wary of any talks between Kabul and the unrepentant leadership of the Taliban. If Pakistan presses forward to increase its influence in Afghanistan, India, Iran, China, and even the Arab states might be forced to act, lessening Afghanistan’s chance ever to find peace or stability. – YaleGlobal

Pakistan and the Afghanistan End Game – Part I

Islamabad’s effort for a greater influence in Kabul could undermine prospects for stability
Ahmed Rashid
YaleGlobal, 12 March 2010
 
Wary neighbors: Afghan President Hamid Karzai (left) with Pakistan's Premier Yousuf Raza Gilani, seeking accommodation. (Photo: European Press Photo Agency)

LAHORE. After the failure of high level talks between India and Pakistan over their long running disputes, both countries are now locked in an escalating proxy war in Afghanistan. If no solution is found to reconcile Pakistani and Indian interests in Afghanistan, the coming months might see stepped up terrorist attacks against Indians in Kabul and the return of militants infiltrating Indian Kashmir from Pakistan. The fact that in recent weeks a large number of Taliban operatives have been captured in Pakistan signals an intensified struggle over the fate of Afghanistan rather than a winding down of the conflict.

With Afghan President Hamid Karzai seeking negotiations with the Taliban, some of whom Pakistan distrusts, along with India increasingly concerned about the Pakistan-backed Taliban coming to power in Kabul, the conflict is reaching a new stage of intensity. Even as an intensive US and NATO military offensive against the Taliban is underway in southern Afghanistan, neighboring states are already considering the Americans as good as gone and preparing for an end game scenario with old rivalries renewed.

In recent weeks, a number of Taliban operatives have been captured in Pakistan signals an intensified struggle over the fate of Afghanistan.

While Pakistan charges India with undermining Pakistani influence in Afghanistan, India fears that Pakistan is preparing the ground for pro-Pakistan elements from the Taliban to negotiate with Kabul, in an attempt to force India out of Afghanistan after US forces start a slow withdrawal in July 2011. Meanwhile, a year after Pakistani militant group Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) carried out Mumbai attack they are yet to be brought to justice. Against this backdrop, Indian and Pakistani Foreign Secretaries met in New Delhi (25 February ) but failed to make any progress. Just a day later a suicide squad in Kabul hit two hotels, killing 16 people including 7 Indian civilians and two Indian army majors. Three days later the Afghan government accused LeT of being responsible for the Kabul attack.

In a series of briefings to the Pakistani and foreign media, Pakistani generals have portrayed India as seriously threatening Pakistan, using its embassy and consulates in Afghanistan to harbor, train and fund Baloch separatists who are waging an insurgency in Balochistan province, trying to undermine Pakistan’s influence in Afghanistan and even for backing elements of the Pakistani Taliban. Tensions heightened after four Pakistani workers were gunned down in Kandahar in early March by unknown assailants. The Pakistani media has accused the Indian consulate in Kandahar of organizing the attack.

Pro-military commentators have risen to the occasion demanding that as Pakistan now faces a two front situation, India should be pushed out of Afghanistan by the Taliban or as a pre-condition which the US must accept, if and when peace talks between the Taliban and the Kabul government are held.

India was rattled when the US and NATO agreed at the January 28 London conference to begin “re-integrating” Taliban fighters.

India was seriously rattled when the US and NATO agreed at the January 28 London conference on Afghanistan to begin “re-integrating” Taliban fighters and field commanders and lavishly funding a peace package for them. President Karzai went much further by demanding ‘reconciliation’ with the mainstream Taliban led by Mullah Mohammed Omar. India was aghast at the unanimity of the international community which is tiring of the war in Afghanistan, as India has vociferously opposed any dialogue with the Taliban. 

India sees the Afghan and Pakistani Taliban and Al Qaeda working closely with anti-Indian groups based in Pakistani Punjab, such as LeT who have begun to re-infiltrate into Indian Kashmir to restart the guerrilla war which has been dormant since 2004. Even US officials say that Punjabi militants are increasingly fighting with the Taliban in Afghanistan.

Although Karzai has declared that “Afghanistan does not want proxy war between India and Pakistan,” India’s real concern is that Pakistan appears determined to position itself center stage of any dialogue between the Taliban and Kabul. The ISI recently arrested key Afghan Taliban leaders who have been engaged in talks with representatives of the Karzai administration without Pakistan’s ISI being involved.

Senior US officials in Washington say the initial arrest of the powerful second in command Taliban leader, Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar in Karachi in early February was accidental – after the CIA discovered the location of a meeting of Taliban commanders where Barader was found. The ISI arrested him and then decided to bring in all his supporters resulting in more arrests. Kabul’s request that Barader be extradited was refused. Despite repeated requests, US officials have been given only limited access to question Barader and even less access to question other arrested Taliban.

India’s real concern is that Pakistan appears determined to position itself center stage of any dialogue between the Taliban and Kabul.

However despite his significant sanctuary in Pakistan, Barader was at odds with the ISI talking independently to Karzai’s representatives without taking the ISI into confidence and instead enlisting the help of Saudi Arabia. Over the past twelve months Saudi Arabia has been intermittently involved in helping the two sides hold informal talks that so far have not led to real negotiations, although they have the potential to do so. The Saudis, although close allies of Pakistan, had also appeared willing to keep the ISI out of the dialogue.

The Obama administration is still far from accepting the idea of negotiating with the Taliban leadership and US officials were annoyed with Karzai after the London conference for raising the issue, but the ISI and the military are now forcing the pace to have a three way dialogue between Kabul, Islamabad and the Taliban, while also pushing the US administration to accept such a dialogue and agree to a major role for the ISI.

India has now embarked on a diplomatic offensive to counter Pakistan’s growing role, sending National Security Adviser Shivsankar Menon to Kabul in early March and the Foreign Minister S.M.Krishna to Iran in coming weeks. Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmedinejad’s hastily arranged trip to Afghanistan this week underlined Tehran’s keen interest in the Afghanistan endgame. India has asked Karzai about his secret negotiations with the Taliban and how India can play a role. At the same time India appears to be wanting to rebuild the alliance with Iran, Russia and the Central Asian Republics that opposed the Taliban in the 1990s and supported the non-Pashtun Northern Alliance.

Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmedinejad’s hastily arranged trip to Afghanistan underlined Tehran’s keen interest in the Afghanistan endgame.

Missing as yet from this complicated maneuvering is the US administration which will have to decide soon on supporting Kabul-Taliban talks, if it is not to see its military and economic development offensives in Afghanistan be undermined by growing regional rivalries. Also missing from the equation is Pakistan’s civilian government which has been bypassed in the foreign policy decision making by the military and the ISI. It is well known that the much weakened President Asif Zardari would like to improve relations with India and Afghanistan and encourage trade and investment, rather than foment a new set of regional tensions.

However a too overt Pakistani role is likely to be rejected by Karzai, by Afghanistan’s non-Pashtuns and civil society and even by many Taliban who are tired of fighting and would like to end their dependence on Pakistan.

Any sign of excessive Pakistani influence in Afghanistan would immediately prompt a reaction from India, Iran, China and the Arab Gulf states, which could include backing anti-Pakistan proxies in Afghanistan making it even more difficult for Afghanistan to achieve peace and stability.

Ahmed Rashid is a Pakistani journalist and author, most recently of "Descent into Chaos: The US and the Disaster in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Central Asia."

Rights:Copyright © 2010 Yale Center for the Study of Globalization

Comments on this Article

24 March 2010
who r u will u merrie me
-zubair ahsan , gilgit pakistan
23 March 2010
hi i like to meet people of Pakistan to make new Pakistan please msg my number 03005332865
-TAUQEER AHMED , ISLAMABAD
23 March 2010
hi i like to meet people and friend shipe with him 03005332865 GIRL CALL ME
-TAUQEER AHMED , ISLAMABAD
23 March 2010
plz control the loard sheding otherwise give me chance of president of pakistan then see my progress and condition of pakistan.i m waiting ur reply.i m student of MEd.
-Hurryrana , lahore
22 March 2010
hi i m imran i passed BA i freindship wid all my muslims peoples can u are all accepted my friendship i wite yours answer
-imran mehar , gujranwala
19 March 2010
"Peace at home and peace in the world."
-Memo , Turkey
18 March 2010
i want to see tha world on my pc
-amir , lahor
18 March 2010
hai i am sam my id is samhot0323@yahoo.com my mobile 0323@yahoo.com i am seking a girls for frind ship
-sam , lalpul mugalpurah lahore pakistan punjab...
18 March 2010
hai i am sam my id is samhot0323@yahoo.com my mobile 0323@yahoo.com i am seking a girls for frind ship
-sam , lalpul mugalpurah lahore pakistan punjab...
15 March 2010
dj9gc
-chicky , Step